I have finally finished my Easter meat-binge.
I’ve already eaten all of the mainstream animals (lamb, pig, cow and chicken) and also managed to squeeze some escargot in there too for good measure. I’m yet to re-sample the delights of certain cuts of these animals, and later this week will be working on some of the more adventurous meats like venison. My gut is also still free from any aquatic delicacies, but this is again something I’m sure will be rectified soon enough.
I clearly succeeded in my first goal of lentetarianism. I actually over succeeded, as lent was somewhat longer than I had originally anticipated. I have astounded my friends and family, and myself, with my will power! But did I make any difference whatsoever with my second goal? Have I become any more environmentally friendly by cutting out meat for 7 weeks?
I calculated my carbon footprint with the WWF ‘footprint’ calculator’ at http://footprint.wwf.org.uk/, once with a meaty diet and once without. As a die-hard carnivore that eats meat at least once a day I apparently lived my life as if I had 2.59 planets worth of resources, with a carbon footprint of 12.4 tonnes per year. Reduce that consumption to never, and it drops to 2.48 planets and 12.31 tonnes. That’s a drop of 0.11 planets, or 0.9 tonnes. The percentage of my carbon output from food also dropped from 20% to 17%.
Now, I’m a little sceptical of this calculator because even if you select all of the ‘right’ answers (vegan, only eat local, fully insulated house etc.) you still get a total of 1.63 planets. That means that even if everybody on the planet was an eco-saint we’d still be doomed. Or maybe we are doomed, and it’s entirely accurate. I tried the government carbon calculator at http://carboncalculator.direct.gov.uk/index.html which I’m sure is significantly more accurate, but it is such an enormous faff that I gave up half-way through adding my travel information and don’t know what my final result is. If I ever have a couple of hours free to do it properly I might try to work it out, but there is no way in hell that I’m doing it twice, so I won’t be able to calculate the difference.
Anyway, what I was trying to say was, this drop in carbon output wasn’t quite as high as I was expecting. I was hoping for a massive, mind-blowing reduction that would convince the world that meat isn’t just murder, but also pollution and global warming. In reality removing meat from my diet was about as effective as putting in a couple more energy-saving lightbulbs. A couple of people said to me in the early days, “It’s not going to make any difference, I don’t see why you bother”. I hate this attitude and think it’s one of the lowest personality traits imaginable, but I have to say I think they may have been right. Not technically correct, but functionally correct; not eating meat for lent made no noticeable difference to anything apart from my sanity.
I’m sure a large part of this is just me making excuses to go back to being a complete carnivore, and I should try to be a little bit more positive about the whole experience. It is true that the meat industry is unsustainable and very polluting, so even the tiniest reduction in its effects is surely a positive thing. I have also learned how to cook some delicious vegetarian food, so if nothing else I’ve made some large personal gains.
WHAT I HAVE LEARNED:
1. I am not a herbivore, and never will be. I really, really tried but it is just not for me.
2. My will power can be fantastic.
3. There is no point going out for a Sunday roast if you’re not going to eat meat because it’s a waste of time and the potatoes will probably be cooked in animal fat anyway if the chef has any sense.
4. I make fantastic pastry. I’d dabbled in mince pies and things before, but during lent made several quiches and vegetable pies and, if you allow me to blow my own horn for a second here, my pastry is amazing.
5. Eating a more sustainable diet is possible, and not actually very difficult.
Now what?
During my ‘time off’ I paid a little more attention to food labels than I ever have previously and realised that most of my food comes from ridiculous places. Half the potatoes I eat come from Holland or Spain, and I’d bet my student loan that my breakfast bananas aren’t locally sourced. A far better way to achieve my ‘eco-warrior!’ title is probably to eat local, and eat seasonal. Do I really need to eat fresh raspberries in February?
Watch this space…

